Short answer: RI answers “is this fair on rarity and fusion cost?” A demand-weighted list answers “what are traders accepting today?” They disagree because they use different inputs. Use RI for a number you can recompute; use a list when demand is what you need to price. For a big trade, use both — not an average.
For the scale itself, plus the twelve pets people look up most, see Adopt Me values.
“What is this trade worth?” is a price question; it moves with demand and availability. “Is this fair?” is a comparison question, and a comparison needs a benchmark. RI benchmarks rarity and the pets consumed by fusion; a demand list benchmarks its reading of the market. Most disagreements come from answering one question with the other’s tool.
RI is base(rarity) × variant. Base: Common 1, Uncommon 2, Rare 4, Ultra-Rare 8, Legendary 16. Normal ×1, Neon ×4, Mega Neon ×16; Fair means the totals differ by at most 10% of the larger total. That is the whole input.
| Rarity | Normal RI | Neon (×4) | Mega Neon (×16) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Common | 1 | 4 | 16 |
| Uncommon | 2 | 8 | 32 |
| Rare | 4 | 16 | 64 |
| Ultra-Rare | 8 | 32 | 128 |
| Legendary | 16 | 64 | 256 |
RI does not measure demand, hype, availability beyond rarity, the Limited flag, potions, eggs, toys, vehicles, liquidity or scam risk.
Elvebredd’s FAQ says “a combination between demand and availability determines the value of pets”; its footer says there are no official values in Adopt Me (elvebredd.com, checked 2026-10-30). Adopt Me Values (GG) describes its calculator as a way to “compare demand” and its homepage as “live market data updated daily” (adoptmevalues.gg/calculator, checked 2026-10-30). Those are their descriptions; we do not know their weights.
Four gaps: demand premium (same rarity, different want); availability (a Limited pet can be scarce); variant demand (a Neon or Mega is a separate item and can trade above or below fusion cost); timing and coverage (lists move on their own schedule and may cover more items). The dimension-by-dimension comparison goes through them without competitor numbers.
| Your question | Use RI | Use a demand-weighted list |
|---|---|---|
| Fair on rarity? | Yes — recomputable. | No — different question. |
| Going rate today? | No — demand not an input. | Yes — that is its job. |
| Neon or Mega pet count? | Yes — ×4 and ×16. | Only if quoted separately. |
| Does the Limited flag matter? | Recorded, not priced. | Usually — availability input. |
| Potions, eggs or vehicles included? | No — not in RI. | If covered. |
| Second opinion on a big trade? | Yes — rarity floor. | Yes — market side. |
All three use pets from the current snapshot (Adopt Me! Wiki revision 475127, 2026-10-23; 805 pets). RI is arithmetic; the demand side is qualitative.
RI: Dragon is Legendary, base 16. Beaver is Rare, base 4; a Neon Beaver is 4 × 4 = 16. The trade is 16 vs 16: Fair.
Demand side: if the list prices Dragon above the Neon’s fusion cost, the Dragon side wins and you (giving Dragon) lose. If it values the Neon Beaver more, the verdict flips. Check the variant labels and whether it quotes Neons separately.
RI: Unicorn is Legendary, base 16. Neon Unicorn = 16 × 4 = 64; four normal Unicorns = 4 × 16 = 64. Fair.
Demand side: if the list carries a Neon variant premium, the Neon side wins; if it values four separate pets above one Neon, the four-Unicorn side wins. Check whether the list has a Neon entry or derives Neons from normal values.
RI: Dog is Common, base 1. Mega Neon Dog = 1 × 16 = 16. Griffin is Legendary, base 16. Fair.
Demand side: Griffin is in the wiki’s Limited category; a Mega Neon Dog can be made from sixteen dogs. A list that prices availability may favor Griffin; a list that treats the Mega as a status item may favor the Mega. Check the Limited flag and whether the list tracks Mega variants.
Neon Turtle vs Mega Neon Unicorn looks lopsided on RI: 64 against 256, so the Mega side wins by 4×. Three public value lists checked on 6 November 2026 put the same pair in the opposite order: each listed a Neon Turtle at 3.4× to 4.5× a Mega Neon Unicorn (AdoptMeTradingValues, The Adopt Me Values, AMVGG; the lists quote different units, so we compare ratios, not raw numbers). Both pets are Legendary. The gap comes from availability and demand: the Turtle is a limited 2020 Aussie Egg pet, and the Unicorn has been available since 2019, still from the Retired Egg. This is the case the next section’s “read the gap” rule is for. Full Turtle vs Unicorn check.
We would add a demand input if it could be checked, dated and reproduced: an openly licensed dataset of completed trades; a list that publishes its weights and values under a licence; or a game source that publishes demand directly. Until then, a numeric RI-to-market conversion would be invented precision. A demand source would be an optional input, not a replacement for the formula anyone can check.
RI compares rarity and fusion cost; a demand list also prices demand and availability. A same-rarity trade can be a loss on a list that values one side higher.
They answer different questions: Elvebredd tracks demand and availability; RI is a benchmark you can recompute.
Yes. Type the number you trust into the value box; the 10% rule uses it.
No. The Limited flag is recorded but not priced, so a Limited Legendary and a non-Limited one both show 16 RI.
RI for the rarity floor, a demand list for the going rate. If they disagree, read the gap instead of averaging.
Playing Blox Fruits too? The Blox Fruits trade calculator adds both sides in published Beli prices and lists seven trades where its Win / Fair / Lose verdict differs from two demand-based calculators. Values checked 2026-11-06.
Updated .