Short answer: the disagreement is in the input, not the arithmetic. Elvebredd, Adopt Me Values (GG) and similar sites publish values built from trading and demand. PetTradeCalc computes RI from the wiki’s official rarity and the Neon/Mega Neon fusion cost. A popular pet can sit above its RI on a demand-weighted list; RI does not estimate that premium.
The scale those lists are compared against is set out on Adopt Me values.
| Dimension | Demand-weighted value lists (Elvebredd, GG and similar) | PetTradeCalc RI |
|---|---|---|
| Input | Trading observations, demand ratings and team judgment, as each site describes its own values | Wiki rarity category plus Normal/Neon/Mega variant; nothing else |
| Demand | Included. GG’s calculator says it compares demand; both sites explain demand in their value help pages | Excluded by design |
| Neon / Mega Neon | Valued as separate trade items, so demand can move a specific Neon away from its fusion cost | Fixed ×4 and ×16, mirroring fusion |
| Item coverage | Often pets, eggs, toys, vehicles, stickers and more | Pets only in the current dataset |
| Update trigger | Whenever the maintainers revise a value; GG says its values are updated daily | Only when the wiki rarity data changes |
| Reproducible by you | You can read the published number, not the weighting behind it | Formula plus public snapshot reproduces every number |
| Fair verdict | Their calculator applies its own comparison to their values | |A − B| ≤ 10% of the larger RI total |
Descriptions of the other sites come from their own public pages, read 2026-10-30. We do not reproduce their numbers or claim to know their internal weights.
Check a trade in the calculator →
We do not publish a numeric conversion between the lists. Their values are proprietary, change on their own schedule, and cannot be verified from outside; a single “conversion factor” would be invented precision. The dimensions above explain the gap without pretending to price it.
Marketplace-based calculators such as StarPets and Traderie follow the same demand-based logic according to their public descriptions; the gap explained above applies to them too.
Sources: elvebredd.com (reviewed 2026-10-27), adoptmevalues.gg/calculator and adoptmevalues.gg (read 2026-10-30), Adopt Me! Wiki revision 475127 (CC BY-SA 3.0, retrieved 2026-10-26); counts and changelog on the data version page.
No. Their lists are not openly licensed, so the calculator uses the wiki rarity data and the published RI formula. You can type any number you trust into the value box and the 10% rule will use it.
Because the list includes demand and PetTradeCalc does not. Popularity, scarcity and demand for a specific Neon or Fly/Ride variant move a list value; RI keeps every pet of one rarity at the same base.
They answer different questions. RI is a reproducible rarity benchmark; a demand-weighted list tracks what traders currently accept. Accuracy against real trades depends on the market and the day, so check both when the trade matters.
Yes. Add the pets here for the rarity check, look up the same pets on the list you trust, then type the list’s value into the value box. Do not average the two: they measure different things.
Playing Blox Fruits too? The Blox Fruits trade calculator adds both sides in published Beli prices and lists seven trades where its Win / Fair / Lose verdict differs from two demand-based calculators. Values checked 2026-11-06.
Are Blox Fruits values the same everywhere? The Blox Fruits values list compares dealer prices with two community value lists and shows why the same fruit has two numbers.
Updated .