PetTradeCalc vs Elvebredd vs AdoptMeTradingValues

Short answer: the two community sites publish demand-based value lists; PetTradeCalc publishes a transparent rarity formula. They answer different questions, so many traders check both. Facts about the other sites come from their own home pages, read 2026-10-27.

Comparison

PetTradeCalcElvebreddAdoptMeTradingValues
Value basisRarity Index: rarity tier ×4 Neon ×16 Mega Neon (published formula)Community value list maintained by its teamCommunity value list with user value suggestions
Demand includedNo (stated on every page)Yes, through its value updatesYes, plus a demand list
Data sourceAdopt Me! Wiki rarities, CC BY-SA 3.0, with revision datesOwn value teamOwn team and user suggestions
Extra featuresWin/Fair/Lose calculator, egg odds, ES/PT pagesValue calculator, trade center, value updatesW/F/L, trading, auctions, demand list; free account option
Account neededNoNot for the calculatorOptional free account
Best forA transparent, explainable sanity checkChecking a demand-based community valueCommunity trading and demand trends

Why the numbers differ

This table compares features. For the dimensions behind a different result — demand, variant demand, update timing — read why our results differ from demand-weighted lists.

Which to use

Citable data: Rarity Index by tier

RarityPets trackedNormal RINeon RIMega Neon RI
Legendary2471664256
Ultra-Rare230832128
Rare15841664
Uncommon1042832
Common661416

805 pets from the Adopt Me! Wiki (CC BY-SA 3.0). Formula: methodology. Generated 2026-10-26.

Sources (read 2026-10-27)

FAQ

Are Elvebredd or AdoptMeTradingValues values official?

No. Elvebredd’s own site states there are no official values in Adopt Me; community lists are maintained by their teams and users. PetTradeCalc’s Rarity Index is not official either — it is a formula anyone can check.

Why would PetTradeCalc disagree with a value list?

Value lists try to track demand. The Rarity Index only uses official rarity and Neon/Mega Neon fusion cost, so a high-demand pet can be worth more in trades than its RI suggests.

Can I use a value list number in PetTradeCalc?

Yes. Type any value into the value box for an item; the Win/Fair/Lose maths then uses your number.

Updated .